A bear checking station sign outside the Mt. Nebo Wildlife Management Area in Garrett County on Monday shows black bear hunters where to bring their bears for biological screenings after the hunt. Photo by Robert Stewart/Capital News Service
By Robert Stewart
Bear hunting season opened this week in Maryland’s westernmost counties, with almost 1,000 hunters licensed to participate in six days of what the state refers to as its “bear population management program.”
But as the bear population rises and animals wander toward more populated areas of the state, hunting as a means of population control remains controversial.
“As you can imagine, the black bear hunt is a hot topic at times,” said Jonathan Trudeau, the game mammal section leader of the wildlife and heritage service of Maryland’s Department of Natural Resources.
The hunting range is limited to Garrett, Allegany, Washington and Frederick counties, where black bears are more abundant, but Trudeau said there are “reports of bears on a fairly regular basis in Montgomery County, Howard County, Carroll and even Baltimore (counties) at this point.”
For hunters, bear season is a rare opportunity to protect humans from wild animals. Over 4,500 hunters had hoped to win an opportunity to bear hunt during this year’s bear season, but only 950 were selected. They’re supposed to follow strict regulations that prohibit baiting and limit the use of dogs and certain firearms.
For Maryland conservationists, the six-day hunting season means revenue for bear population research and management. The DNR-managed hunt is one part of the state’s multipronged effort to understand and manage Maryland’s growing black bear population.
But animal rights groups say lethal means are not the best way of managing the growing number of bears.
“The Humane Society of the United States opposes all forms of trophy hunting,” said Jennifer Bevan-Dangel, the society’s state director, “and that certainly includes black bear hunting and the hunt here in Maryland.”
Bevan-Dangel believes there are other ways to deal with the bears, which do not pose a big threat to humans right now. According to the DNR’s site, there have been only two reported bear attacks in Maryland. Residents can help to avoid conflicts with bears by learning how not to attract them, she said.
“You can’t hunt your way out of conflict, especially with this species,” she said. “We’re neither convinced that this level of lethal population management is necessary or that it’s effective.”
Bevan-Dangel said humans could live more harmoniously with the American black bear by following a few simple guidelines, like avoiding encounters and trying not to lure the animals. They can do this by cleaning grills, bringing bird feeders inside and securing trash cans, she said, because the smell of tasty treats is often what brings the animals around.
“Even if one bear is hunted and removed,” she said, “another bear is certainly going to come along.”
There was a time when managing the bear population meant banning hunting, not permitting it.
In the 1950s, the bears were nearly extinct in Maryland, according to the DNR. So in 1953, state lawmakers banned bear hunting. The ban, coupled with improvements to bear habitat, led to a rebound in the population.
In 2003, when a black bear task force voted to reinstate bear hunting, the population was estimated to be between 266 and 437 animals in Maryland. The bears were mainly concentrated in what the DNR calls the “occupied bear range” in the state’s westernmost counties.
Now, 20 years later, Maryland’s black bear population has grown and spread.
Trudeau said the DNR estimates roughly 2,000 bears are in the state, and there are indications the population is healthy and increasing. The agency monitors bear populations by visiting dens, counting reproduction rates, tracking complaints of run-ins with bears and using “scent sites.” That method involves hanging sardine cans in particular sites and monitoring bear visits.
“It’s not a trophy hunt by any stretch of the imagination,” said Trudeau, contradicting the HSUS’ categorization of bear hunting in Maryland. “It’s an extremely, extremely restricted hunt and they only have six days to harvest a bear.”
The restrictions include a limit of one bear per hunter, and limitations on the use of hounds, bait and electronic “calls” – devices used to lure bears. The DNR also mandates that every bear hunted be brought into a bear hunt checking stations, where officials collect biological data on the bears, and hunters identify the site of the kill.
The checking stations help Maryland scientists better understand bears, model the population and predict how various management actions – like hunting – can impact bear populations in the future, said Trudeau.
“When that bear comes into this check station, it provides us, as the biologist, with a unique opportunity to collect a wide variety of data,” said Trudeau.
“Our goal is to essentially slow the eastward expansion of the population,” he said, “and have a stable, a very healthy black bear population.”