NEW YORK, NEW YORK – JUNE 11: Sen. Bob Menendez (D-NJ) arrives for trial at Manhattan Federal Court on June 11, 2024 in New York City. Jose Uribe, who is cooperating with federal prosecutors in their case against Menendez, testified on Monday. He will continue his testimony regarding a backyard meeting with the senator in September 2019. Menendez along with his wife Nadine are facing bribery charges. The indictment is the second in eight years against Menendez. The indictment also includes charges for Wael Hana, Fred Daibes, and Uribe who are cooperating with federal prosecutors in hopes of a lenient sentence. Nadine Menendez’s trial is expected to take place later this summer. (Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)
On Friday, the 26th day of the federal corruption trial of Sen. Bob Menendez, prosecutors rested their case against New Jersey’s senior senator and two of his codefendants.
The trial began in mid-May and has seen more than two dozen witnesses testify in front of U.S. District Judge Sidney H. Stein at the Daniel Patrick Moynihan federal courthouse in Manhattan, including U.S. Attorney Philip Sellinger, former state Attorney General Gurbir Grewal, two former Menendez advisers, and more.
Prosecutors hope they can convince the jury that Menendez accepted lavish bribes in exchange for his interference in foreign policy matters and domestic criminal investigations. Menendez’s lawyers have argued his actions were that of a U.S. senator doing his job.
As the defense prepares to present its case, here are key moments in the prosecution’s case against Menendez and codefendants Wael “Will” Hana and Fred Daibes. Menendez’s wife, Nadine, is also charged and is expected to be tried later this year.
Cash everywhere
FBI agents found so much cash in Menendez’s home in Englewood Cliffs that they had to get someone to bring an automated cash counter to add it all up.
“The sheer volume of bills that we encountered was too much to count by hand,” said Aristotelis Kougemitros, the FBI special agent who led the search.
The money — $486,461 in cash, along with 13 gold bars — was jammed into jackets and boots and crammed into bags and boxes around the couple’s cluttered home.
FBI agents found $486,461 in cash stuffed in bags and boxes during their June 2022 search of the Englewood Cliffs home of Sen. Bob Menendez and his wife Nadine. (Courtesy of U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York)
‘Very shady’ meat monopoly
Prosecutors allege Hana’s monopoly on exporting halal meat to Egypt wasn’t because of Hana’s business acumen, but because of bribes he gave Menendez and the senator’s favors to benefit the Egyptian government at Hana’s behest.
U.S. Department of Agriculture official James Bret Tate testified that he wanted to push back against Egypt’s decision to make Hana’s company their sole importer of halal-certified meat, but Egypt wouldn’t meet with him. And that was unusual, he said.
“When the American embassy requests a meeting, we get meetings,” Tate said.
Text Sen. Bob Menendez sent to his wife Nadine about a U.S. sale of military ammunition to Egypt. (Courtesy U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York)
‘The love email’
Menendez lost a bid to keep jurors from seeing what has been dubbed the “love email,” a text he sent Nadine Menendez telling her to inform Hana that the senator was signing off on arms to Egypt.
The senator’s lawyers argued that the speech and debate clause of the U.S. Constitution — which provides immunity to lawmakers performing official legislative acts — applied here, but Stein said a promise to perform an act is itself not a legislative act.
Prosecutors say releasing aid and arms to Egypt — which historically has received the most military aid from the U.S. of any other country except Israel — is one of the things Menendez did to help Hana protect his monopoly.
Keeping Nadine happy
Prosecutors say Nadine Menendez was a go-between linking her husband with the businessmen accused of bribing him.
Attorney Howard Dorian, who represented Hana, made this clear in a text he sent to one man involved in one of the alleged bribery schemes.
“It is extremely important that we keep Nadine happy,” Dorian wrote.
Texts also show how Nadine Menendez suggested talking points to Sen. Menendez at Hana’s direction.
“In your speech, could you please say Egypt now in the right direction with the new government now. With the International Monetary Fund and all the new developments, new capital and the new Suez Canal. Egypt is important to the United States,” she texted Sen. Menendez.
‘Stop interfering’
A former U.S. Department of Agriculture official told jurors Menendez called him when the department was looking into why Egypt chose to get halal meat from just Hana’s company.
“Stop interfering with my constituents,” Menendez said, according to the ex-official, Ted McKinney.
The Mercedes-Benz
When Nadine Menendez needed a new car after totaling hers in a crash that killed a pedestrian in Bogota, businessman Jose Uribe stepped in to help.
Uribe had an associate facing prosecution by the state Attorney General’s Office, and a related expanding investigation threatened to ensnare Uribe’s own business. So he made “a deal” with Nadine Menendez — a car in exchange for her husband’s help in squashing his criminal troubles, he told jurors. He provided a down payment and made monthly payments for Nadine’s new car for almost three years, testimony showed.
After Nadine Menendez signed paperwork for the Mercedes-Benz, she texted her husband.
“The car is home,” she wrote.
“Woopy!!!” the senator texted back.
To Uribe, she texted: “You are a miracle worker who makes dreams come true. I will always remember that.”
Uribe was charged along with the Menendezes but pleaded guilty in March in a cooperation deal with prosecutors.
Federal prosecutors say Nadine Menendez received this Mercedes Benz convertible as a bribe from Jose Uribe. (Courtesy of U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York)
‘Gross’
Grewal, the former New Jersey attorney general, told jurors that Menendez tried to speak to him three times about the charges facing Uribe’s associate.
The last time was at Menendez’s Newark office, where Grewal and colleague Andrew Bruck met with the senator. Afterward, Grewal testified, Bruck had this to say: “Whoa, that was gross.”
Grewal conceded Menendez made no “explicit ask” during the meeting or phone calls and was “polite” throughout their interactions.
“What I understood the upshot of this conversation to be was that he didn’t like how this matter was being handled by our office and wanted it handled differently,” Grewal said.
‘Yes, I did’
Uribe took the stand to say he did indeed bribe Menendez hoping the senator would kill the investigations that focused on his associate and business.
“I agreed with Nadine Menendez and other people to provide a car for Nadine in order to get the power and influence of Mr. Menendez,” Uribe said.
Uribe also testified that Menendez acknowledged his interference.
“I saved your little a** not once, but twice,” Uribe said the senator told him in Spanish.
New Jersey businessman Jose Uribe, 56, arrives at Manhattan court after being indicted on bribery charges in conjunction with Senator Bob Menendez and his wife Nadine Menendez on October 2, 2023 in New York City. (Photo by David Dee Delgado/Getty Images)
Former friends
Sellinger said while Menendez was considering him to be New Jersey’s new U.S. attorney in 2020, Menendez told Sellinger that the office’s prosecution of Daibes, a real estate developer charged with bank fraud, was unfair.
“Sen. Menendez hoped that if I became U.S. attorney, I would look at it carefully,” Sellinger told jurors.
When Sellinger said he might be recused from the Daibes case because of a conflict of interest, Menendez chose another candidate, Hudson County Prosecutor Esther Suarez, Sellinger said. When that fell through, Sellinger got the job — and then, when his new bosses ordered him off the Daibes matter, Menendez ended their friendship, he testified.
Behind-the-scenes
Michael Soliman, a former Menendez adviser, explained how he helped Menendez shield Suarez’s potential nomination as U.S. attorney from public scrutiny by falsely claiming there were other candidates and by planting fake stories in the press.
“It was my job to protect the senator, so I just cared about his optics,” said Soliman.
Soliman also said he met with Sellinger after he became the U.S. attorney — Menendez had asked Soliman to tell Sellinger to give Daibes “all due process” — but Sellinger warned him at the start of the meal not to bring up any pending criminal matter or Sellinger would have to alert the Department of Justice.
Qatar
Prosecutors allege Daibes bribed Menendez to score investments from a Qatari royal, and that the deal almost went south because the royal learned of Daibes’ bank fraud case. Menendez stepped in to meet with Sheikh Sultan bin Jassim Al Thani, whose brother is Qatar’s emir, and other Qatari royals to smooth things over, prosecutors say.
“I hope that this will result in the favorable and mutually beneficial agreement that you both have been engaged in discussing,” Menendez wrote to bin Jassim in an encrypted WhatsApp message in January 2022.
Four months later, Daibes and a firm the sheikh founded signed a $190 million deal.
Egypt
Sarah Arkin, a former foreign policy adviser to Menendez, told jurors Menendez started acting “weird” regarding Egypt at about the time prosecutors say Hana was bribing him to keep his lucrative halal deal.
Arkin said Menendez started meeting with Egyptian officials without her, contrary to their usual protocol.
“A critical part of my job is preparing him for those meetings,” Arkin said. “I didn’t know exactly who he was talking to or what information he had or didn’t have or who he might want to meet or where information was coming from.”
FBI agents found 13 gold bars during their June 2022 search of the Englewood Cliffs home of Sen. Bob Menendez and his wife, Nadine. (Courtesy of U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York)
Gold bars
Jeweler Vasken Khorozian said Nadine Menendez cashed in about $250,000 worth of gold bars in 2022, just weeks before the FBI searched the Menendez home and found more gold bars and cash.
Khorozian said she came to his Edgewater store three times that spring, initially telling him she was trading in the bars because she had a “financial situation.”
Prosecutors can’t say whether those gold bars were given to the Menendezes by Daibes or Hana — Khorozian did not take down their serial numbers.
“If I know what I know now, I would do things differently,” Khorozian said.
Disclosures
A Senate ethics director said income, assets, gifts, and liabilities of both senators and their spouses must be disclosed, so that constituents can see for themselves their representative’s financial situation.
But if the gold bars, cash, and other valuables the Menendezes took from Daibes, Hana, and Uribe were indeed loans and gifts as the defense team contends, the senator should have reported them on mandatory annual disclosure forms, said Shannon Kopplin, chief counsel and staff director of the U.S. Senate Select Committee on Ethics.
He did not, Kopplin said.
In February 2022, about 16 months after he got married, Kopplin said she got a call from the senator, who had questions about how to report gold bars he said belonged to his wife.
The next month, he officially disclosed his wife’s gold, Kopplin said. Three months later, FBI agents seized it as evidence.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The post Sen. Menendez’s lawyers begin their defense Monday. Here are key elements of prosecutors’ case. appeared first on New Jersey Monitor.